Today, I went to A2 Book Fest to vend with the Great Lakes Association of Horror Writers, of which I’m a member. Not wanting to be intrusive, I asked the secretary of GLAHW if it was okay that I bring a couple copies of Clean Freak to sell. He said that was okay. So I did, with no real expectations.
I sold all three copies that I brought.
And I helped sell all three copies of Erie Tales 17: Cursed Objects that includes my story, “Dashboard Jesus.”
And a woman came back and was actually upset that we had sold out of ET:CO.
So yeah… good day.
On Saturday, a writer that I follow on Bluesky, Susan Savage Lee, posed the question, “Writers, what helped you write a good plot summary of your novels? I’m trying to find a good balance with details.”
I responded, “When I was first going to pitch Clean Freak, I had about a five minute pitch that my partner helped me craft. I mean, a solid five minutes of me talking. Then, going to the pitch prep panel at my first World Horror Con, the publishers basically blew my plan up. It depends on if you’re pitching verbally or in writing. If in writing, the process described by the first commenter is a good one. If verbally, start with an elevator pitch that makes them ask for the one minute pitch that makes them ask for the five minute pitch. This is also to have when you’re vending at events.”
That one sentence is how I pitched Clean Freak to editors and publishers and it’s what I continue to use to pitch it to potential readers:
“It’s about a man with severe OCD and the ghost of a little girl who lives in his shower drain.”
I’ve never had it not get a reaction out of folks. Most people want to know more, either picking up the book and reading the back, or asking me to tell them more. I also have a secret weapon for this particular story: I have a favorite paragraph, which I usually bookmark prior to the start of vending events. I’ve only ever had a few people set the book back down after reading that paragraph. It’s a pretty good one.
Talking to folks about ET:CO, I extemporaneously came up with a similar pitch for “Dashboard Jesus:”
“It’s about a vengeful Jesus figurine on the dash of a stolen car.”
People loved the story pitch and the anthology flew off the wire rack. One woman who had breezed through earlier in the day came back over and we had to tell her that we’d sold out of that one. She was surprisingly upset. But I wrote down the title of the anthology and of my story so she could find it to order when she got home. That touched me deeply. It’s one thing to be caught up in the moment and swayed by a good pitch. It’s another to be so affected by a story pitch that you seek it out past the initial moment.
It’s nice to know I still got it!